The PC Revolution
PC's are gaining momentum in the world
of control. PLC's are quickly becoming obsolete under the power that PC
control brings. As with any new technology there is a natural reluctance
to the change that it brings. PC control has been field proven time and
time again and is the control system of the future. PC's have been recently
acknowledged for their superior control ability. A few examples of such
acknowledgement are listed below:
During the 1998 MBAA District Ontario's
Annual One Day Technical Seminar, Dave Bambrick from Molson Breweries (Ontario)
presented a session entitled "PLC's vs. PC's Issues
to Consider for Brewery Automation". Excerpts from this session
are summarized below:
Disadvantages of PLC's that PC's have
overcome:
-
High initial cost to purchase a PLC system
-
Costly to upgrade the PLC when you want to expand or
modify your existing technology
-
Difficult to connect to other systems
-
PLC's are slow to add new features to their systems
-
Proprietary hardware and software (locked into a chosen
supplier for life of equipment)
Also:
-
PLC control systems have a long development time to
create a program to operate your system
-
Problems are difficult to debug (RLL could have 300
to 400 lines to check)
-
Increased downtime because of debugging problems
-
Extensive training required to learn how to maintain
and operate the PLC system
-
Difficult to modify or change programming (again, RLL
could be large 300 to 400 lines)
From the 1997 December Issue of The McGraw-Hill
Companies' Chemical Engineering Magazine there is a two part article entitled,
"The Emergence of PC Technology" by
Mike Santori and "Controlling the Future"
written by Phil White and Gary George. A comprehensive section from that
article is available below:
Click here
to view the image pc-article.jpg (319K)
Home